| 6 | Clifford Monmohan Agarwala | 9 Jan 1948 – 24 Jan 1950 | 2 yrs 16 days | — |
| 7 | Herbert Ribton Meredith | 25 Jan 1950 – 7 Apr 1950 | 73 days | — |
| 8 | Pandit Lakshami Kant Jha | 8 Apr 1950 – 31 May 1952 | 2 yrs 54 days | — |
| 9 | David Ezra Reuben | 1 Jun 1952 – 2 Sep 1953 | 1 yr 94 days | — |
| 10 | Syed Jafar Imam | 3 Sep 1953 – 9 Jan 1955 | 1 yr 129 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 11 | Sudhansu Kumar Das | 10 Jan 1955 – 29 Apr 1956 | 1 yr 111 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 12 | V. Ramaswami | 30 Apr 1956 – 3 Jan 1965 | 8 yrs 249 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 13 | R. L. Narasimham | 4 Jan 1965 – 2 Aug 1968 | 3 yrs 212 days | — |
| 14 | Satish Chandra Sharma | 9 Nov 1968 – 4 Sep 1970 | 1 yr 300 days | — |
| 15 | Ujjal Narayan Sinha | 5 Sep 1970 – 28 Sep 1972 | 2 yrs 24 days | — |
| 16 | Nand Lall Untwalia | 29 Sep 1972 – 2 Oct 1974 | 2 yrs 4 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 17 | Shyam Nandan Prasad Singh | 3 Oct 1974 – 1 May 1976 | 1 yr 212 days | — |
| 18 | Krishna Ballabh Narayan Singh | 19 Jul 1976 – 12 Mar 1982 | 5 yrs 237 days | Transferred to Madras |
| 19 | Surjit Singh Sandhawalia | 29 Nov 1983 – 27 Jul 1987 | 3 yrs 241 days | — |
| 20 | Bhagwati Prasad Jha | 2 Jan 1988 | 1 day | Shortest tenure |
| 21 | Dipak Kumar Sen | 1 May 1988 – 1 May 1989 | 1 yr 1 day | — |
| 22 | Shushil Kumar Jha | 19 Oct 1989 – 23 Oct 1989 | 5 days | Transferred to MP |
| 23 | Gangadhar Ganesh Sohani | 24 Oct 1989 – 17 Dec 1990 | 1 yr 55 days | — |
| 24 | Bimal Chandra Basak | 18 Mar 1991 – 21 Oct 1993 | 2 yrs 218 days | — |
| 25 | K. S. Paripoornan | 24 Jan 1994 – 10 Jun 1994 | 141 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 26 | K. Venkataswamy | 19 Sep 1994 – 5 Mar 1995 | 168 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 27 | Gopal Ballav Pattanaik | 19 May 1995 – 10 Sep 1995 | 115 days | Later 32nd CJI |
| 28 | Devinder Pratap Wadhwa | 29 Sep 1995 – 20 Mar 1997 | 1 yr 173 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 29 | Brij Mohan Lal | 9 Jul 1997 – 6 Oct 1999 | 2 yrs 90 days | — |
| 30 | Ravi Swaroop Dhavan | 25 Jan 2000 – 22 Jul 2004 | 4 yrs 180 days | — |
| 31 | J. N. Bhatt | 18 Jul 2005 – 16 Oct 2007 | 2 yrs 91 days | — |
| 32 | Rajesh Balia | 5 Jan 2008 – 3 Mar 2008 | 59 days | — |
| 33 | Rajendra Mal Lodha | 13 May 2008 – 16 Dec 2008 | 218 days | Later 41st CJI |
| 34 | Jacob Benjamin Koshy | 16 Mar 2009 – 12 May 2009 | 58 days | — |
| 35 | Prafulla Kumar Mishra | 12 Aug 2009 – 16 Sep 2009 | 36 days | — |
| 36 | Dipak Misra | 23 Dec 2009 – 23 May 2010 | 152 days | Later 45th CJI |
| 37 | Rekha Manharlal Doshit | 21 Jun 2010 – 12 Dec 2014 | 4 yrs 175 days | — |
| 38 | Lingappa Narasimha Reddy | 2 Jan 2015 – 31 Jul 2015 | 211 days | — |
| 39 | Iqbal Ahmed Ansari | 29 Jul 2016 – 28 Oct 2016 | 92 days | — |
| 40 | Rajendra Menon | 15 Mar 2017 – 8 Aug 2018 | 1 yr 147 days | Transferred to Delhi |
| 41 | Mukesh R. Shah | 12 Aug 2018 – 1 Nov 2018 | 82 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 42 | A. P. Sahi | 17 Nov 2018 – 10 Nov 2019 | 359 days | Transferred to Madras |
| 43 | Sanjay Karol | 11 Nov 2019 – 5 Feb 2023 | 3 yrs 87 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 44 | K. V. Chandran | 29 Mar 2023 – 15 Jan 2025 | 1 yr 293 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| 45 | Vipul Manubhai Pancholi | 21 Jul 2025 – 28 Aug 2025 | 39 days | Elevated to Supreme Court |
| — | Pavankumar B. Bajanthri (Acting) | 29 Aug 2025 – Present | — | Acting Chief Justice |